Pie Society Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Pie Society, a unique fusion of speakeasy charm and vibrant pizza culture nestled in Costa Mesa, CA. This trendy cocktail bar offers an eclectic menu that goes beyond the classic pie, featuring vegan options that ensure everyone can indulge. The ambiance is perfect for both casual dinners and late-night gatherings, with a moderate noise level ideal for conversing.

What sets Pie Society apart is not just their culinary creations but also their comprehensive services. From takeout and delivery to reservations and onsite catering, they ensure a seamless dining experience. Enjoy the outdoor seating on a pleasant evening or take part in their lively happy hour specials.

Highlights include their signature cocktails and artisanal pizzas, each crafted with high-quality ingredients. The mix of hipster elegance and relaxed vibes makes Pie Society a perfect spot for groups or a cozy dinner. Don’t miss out—you will love every bite!

Pie Society

Our Pickles

bread butter, sriracha, dill

$4.00

Pastrami Peanuts, Smoked Sea Salt

$3.00

Smoked, Marinated Olives

$5.00

Trio

our pickles bread butter, sriracha, dill pastrami peanuts, smoked sea salt smoked, marinated olive

$8.00

Sweet Sour Crispy Pork Belly

pineapple opal basil

$8.00

Superba Fried Chicken

red wine vin glaze, parm chilies

$8.00

Crispy Dim Sum Shrimp

black sesame, sweet mayo, pineapple

$8.00

Cheeseburger Hot Pocket

smoked cheddar, dill pickle, house ketchup mustard

$8.00

Tater Tots, Chorizo Fondue

$7.00

Kimchi Deviled Eggs

$4.00

Soprano Pizza

sopprasata, tomato, fresh mozzarella, caramelized onion, castelvetrano olives, fresno chiles, salsa verde

$13.00

Deli Pizza

pastrami meatballs, gouda fondue, caraway, fresh mozzarella, pickled fresn

$12.00

Meatball Appetizer

$6.00

Flatbread With Ricotta

$7.00

Sausage Party Pizza

$12.00

Mushroom Pizza

$10.00

Lamb Merguez, Spinach Feta

$11.00

Pitfire Food Snacks

Beverages Non Alcoholic

Ginger Beer

housemade, on tap, nonalcoholic

$5.00

Old Time Shirley Temple

housemade grenadine, 7up

$5.00

Old Time Roy Rogers

housemade grenadine, cok

$5.00

Grapefruit Soda Pop

housemade

$5.00

Lime Soda Pop

housemade

$5.00

Spiced Soda Pop

cinnamon allspic

$5.00

Fever Tree Tonic

$5.00

Fever Tree Ginger Ale

$5.00

Fever Tree Bitter Lemon

$5.00

7 Up

$4.00

Diet Coke

$4.00

Mexican Coke

$4.00

Pies O Bar House Matini

fords gin, smirnoff vodka, cocchi americano, dolin blanc vermouth, bergamot oil, lemon peel, shaken, up. a nod to the classic vesper martini, as bond himself might have ordered it shaken. to the traditionalist, it should be a stirred cocktail, so weve justified the hardshake with the addition of a few drops of bergamot oil...the familiar note that gives earl grey its character. so this might be what 007 would order for breakfas

$12.00

Old Man The Sea

zaya 12 yo trinidad rum, st. elizabeth allspice dram, barspoon turbinado syrup, lime ribbon, stirred, one rock. the iconic old fashioned is the template around which we shaped this spicy spiritforward sipper. imagine the calm of a southern caribbean evening glass off, tempered by indigenous baking spice, slightly sweet with lime zest wafting overhead...in a glass

$12.00

El Primo

sombra mezcal, housemade lime cordial, lime wheel, shaken, up. imagine if the mexican navy issued their sailors a daily ration of spirits lime...like the british used to do. instead of taking their medicine as a grog rum or gimlet gin they might opt for mezcal. sombras oaksmoked bouquet of tropical fruits spice balances with the sweet confectionery notes zesty vibrance in our lime cordial. orale!

$10.00

Medicine Rattle

chinaco blanco tequila, fresh pineapple juice, green tea jalapeno ss, shiso, sake, shaken, up. shiso is a healing herb, used in cuisine homeopathy throughout asia. it the green tea are the shaman in this meeting of east west. the chili compliments the tequilas vegetal notes without adding heat. sake pineapple weave a base of fruit cereal that is sweet, yet dry familiar...and mysteriously refreshing

$12.00

Pool Side

fords gin, watermelon, lemon juice, plymouth sloe gin, cucumber slice, shaken, over, long. you say you dont like gin...may we try to change your mind about that? the cousin of the southside sportsmens clubs famous long drink its sister, the eastside, this is one for both the men the women. who doesnt like watermelon...and who was it that said they dont like gin

$10.00

Art Of The Kill

deaths door gin, gran classico, cynar, tangerine peel garnish, stirred, one rock. a negroni, reimagined. a different cast plays their parts in homage to counts camillos classic with a voice of their own. deaths door gins 3botanical simplicity soft wheat base allow plenty of room for the torinostyle elixir bittersweet herbal liqueurs to mingle with fragrant tangerine zest

$10.00

House Drinks

Sours

Classic

make it long wseltzer for a collins. choice of spirit bourbon,rye, irish, gin or vodka fresh lemon juice cane simple syrup orange slice cherry garnish shaken, up or over

$10.00

Boston Sour

bourbon rye whiskey, lemon juice, simple syrup, egg white, bitters mist, orange zest garnish

$10.00

Buck

choice of spirit rum, bourbon, rye, gin, tequila or vodka housemade, ginger beer, fresh lime, over, short. moscow mule

$10.00

Hemingway Daiquiri

cana brava, cuban style rum, fresh lime juice, housemade grapefruit cordial, maraschino, frappe

$10.00

Book On The Wall

pick a spirit, pick a book. well pick a drink

New York Sour

rye whiskey, fresh lemon juice, cane simple syrup, red wine float, cherry garnish, shaken, up or over

$12.00

Maid

choice of spirit cognac, bourbon, rye, gin, vodka or bourbon hothouse cucumber fresh lime juice cane simple, mint shaken, over short. kentucky maid

$10.00

Mai Tai

smith cross jamaican rum rhum agricole orange curacao fresh lime juice housemade orgeat mint, orchid garnis

$12.00

Bartenders Choice

spirit? sweet or sour? up or over

Mission Heffe

$6.00

Old Speckled Hen Pub

$7.00

Chimay Blue

$10.00

Avery Ipa

$6.00

Oskar Blues Dales Pale Ale

$6.00

Oaked Arrogant Bastard Ale

$8.00

Noble Ale Works Pistol Whipped Czech Pilsner

$7.00

Allagash Black Belgian Strong Ale

$7.00

Beers

Sparkling

Prosecco, Angelo Bortolin, Valdobbiadene, Italy

$13.00

Chardonnay, Broadside, Edna Valley, Ca

wild ferment

$13.00

Chenin Blanc Blend, Farmers Jane, Jurassic Park Vyd, Santa Barbara, Ca

sustainable

$15.00

White

Rose

Syrah Ampelos, Ampelos, Santa Ynez, Ca

Pinot Noir, Antic, Suisun Valley, Ca

$13.00

Malbec, Tonada, Mendoza Argentina

$12.00

SangioveseMerlotPetit Verdot, Giornata, Central Coast, Ca

sustainable

$15.00

Red